Image courtesy of: Zimbio
South Africa Test captain Faf du Plessis’ appeal against his ball tampering verdict was shot down by judicial commissioner Michael Beloff.
Du Plessis, who recently replaced AB de Villiers as Test captain on a permanent basis, was still found guilty of breaching Law 42.3, but he received no further sanctions on top of being docked 100 per cent of his match fee from the second Test against Australia in Hobart last month, which was when the incident occurred, and being handed three demerit points.
Footage of the 32-year-old licking his fingers with a mint in his mouth and repeatedly rubbing and shining the ball was investigated by the International Cricket Council (ICC), who found him guilty of ball tampering.
Even though Du Plessis insisted that he was innocent on numerous occasions, Beloff ruled in favour of the original sanctions imposed on the Proteas skipper.
The hearing was held on Monday in Dubai, where Du Plessis appeared via video link. Beloff subsequently reserved judgement until Wednesday, but opted not to ban Du Plessis for one match despite confirming that the Pretoria native had “applied the substance to the match ball and did so intentionally”.
Cricket South Africa had asked the ICC to clearly define what was meant by “artificial substance”, but Beloff did not believe the words created any uncertainty.
“As to what is an artificial substance, neither Code, Law nor Guidance define it. The adjective “artificial” is ordinarily used as the opposite of natural,” Beloff wrote in a 14-page judgment. “The Oxford English Dictionary defines it as “made or produced by human beings rather than occurring naturally” which the Appellant was prepared to accept. There is nothing in the regulatory context to require, in my view, any alternative or different definition.”
With that in mind, Beloff ruled that Du Plessis had applied an artificial substance to the ball.
“The saliva/mint or the combination thereof was an “artificial substance” (although the saliva per se is not),” he added. “If the drinking of gin is prohibited it is not a defence to say that it was mixed with tonic.
“The consequence of his (du Plessis’) action was to alter the condition of the ball (or was likely to do) in the relevant sense, that is to say, it altered the status quo ante of the match ball (i.e. 12 its condition prior to the polishing). Whether that can be described as maintenance (i.e. restoring the ball to its pristine condition) or enhancement, (i.e. improving its condition from what it was prior to shining), matters not.”
ICC CEO David Richardson, who admitted to being “disappointed” with Du Plessis’ decision to appeal against the governing body’s verdict, hailed Beloff’s decision.
“It is the duty of the ICC to ensure fair play on the cricket field. Although it was not picked up by the umpires at the time, when the incident came to our attention subsequently, we felt it was our responsibility to lay a charge in this case because the ICC can’t let such an obvious breach of this Law pass without taking any action,” Richardson said. “We are pleased that both the Match Referee and Mr Beloff QC have agreed with our interpretation of the Laws and hope that this serves as a deterrent to all players not to engage in this sort of unfair practice in the future.”
Richardson also made it clear that he was open to changing the ball tampering laws to make sure it is more precise, but added that he feels it clear enough already.
“It goes without saying that we will be reviewing the outcome to determine if any additional guidelines are needed to provide further clarity to the players and umpires around this type of offence. However we are satisfied that the Law is clear and is implemented consistently,” he said.

