Image courtesy of: Zimbio
The New South Wales (NSW) Coroner’s Court ruled on Friday that Australia batsman Phillip Hughes’ death was a “tragic accident” and no one was to blame.
Hughes passed away two days after he was struck on the side of the neck while representing South Australia in a Sheffield Shield game against NSW on November 25, 2014.
After thoroughly reviewing all the circumstances to find out whether Hughes’ death could have been avoided, NSW State Coroner Michael Barnes insisted that he found no evidence to support claims by the Hughes family that the 25-year-old had died in a “very unsafe workplace”.
“The family’s grief at losing their much loved son and brother was exacerbated by their belief that unfair play had contributed to his death,” Barnes said. “It is hoped that they accept the compelling evidence that the rules were complied with. Phillip was excelling at the crease as he so often did and that his death was a tragic accident.”
Barnes added that the injury Hughes sustained was “unsurvivable” no matter how fast emergency services had arrived and how skilled the medical personnel were.
“None of those on the field at the time knew how to summon medical assistance onto the field,” the coroner said. “Although it was immediately obvious that Phillip was injured, it was not clear whose responsibility it was to call an ambulance. An ambulance was not called for over six minutes after he was hit.
“The person who called the ambulance did not have sufficient information to enable an accurate triage to be made by the ambulance dispatcher. As a result, the ambulance response was given a lower order of urgency than it would have been given had the relevant information about Phillip’s condition been conveyed.”
Hughes’ helmet came under review after his death, but Barnes made it clear that the outcome would have been the same had he been wearing more protection.
In May, Cricket Australia made it compulsory for all batsmen to wear helmets when facing fast or medium-pace bowling.
Hughes’ family walked out of the inquest into his death as they believed he had been the victim of threatening language, and that he had been targeted in a spell of short-pitched bowling even though numerous players indicated that this was not the case.
While Barnes accepted that Hughes had been peppered with short-pitched bowling, he pointed out that it wasn’t excessive in amount.
Barnes also admitted that he found it hard to believe no words were directed towards Hughes before adding that sledging tactics should be closer scrutinised.
“Hopefully, the focus on this unsavoury aspect of the incident may cause those who claim to love the game to reflect upon whether the practice of sledging is worthy of its participants,” he said. “An outsider is left to wonder why such a beautiful game would need such an ugly underside.”
Cricket Australia CEO James Sutherland agreed with Barnes’ views on how the game should be played, but made it clear that the current regulations in effect were sufficient.
“If it has become a problem, then I would say the umpires are not doing their job,” he said. “It is very clear in the relevant codes of behaviour, whether we’re talking about the Cricket Australia code or the international code as to what constitutes behaviour that crosses the line, whether that’s audible obscenities, whether that’s verbal or threatening – verbal abuse or threatening behaviour.”

